Band:
Omar Rodríguez-López – guitar, keyboards, synths, bass, direction, arrangements
Cedric Bixler-Zavala – vocals, lyrics
Juan Alderete – bass guitar
Deantoni Parks – drums
Marcel Rodríguez-López (though credited, did not play on the album)
Discography:
De-Loused in the Comatorium (2003)
Frances the Mute (2005)
Amputechture (2006)
The Bedlam in Goliath (2008)
Octahedron (2009)
Guests:
Info:
Omar Rodríguez-López – producer
Lars Stalfors – recording engineer, mixing
Isaiah Abolin – recording engineer
Heba Kadry – mastering
Sonny Kay – artwork, layout, design
Released 28/3-2012
Reviewed 3/6-2012
I think musically it is hard not to draw parallels to the classic progressive rock bands from Britain that were active in the seventies, a style that has come a little bit to life again lately. The Mars Volta is clearly inspired by this kind of music and influences from many of those bands are easy to find while listening through this album that has a great sound and skilled musicianships as well as many innovative musical ideas that are being found all the way through this album. The singer has a somewhat hypnotic way of conveying his vocals and the lyrics are about as incoherent as the musical style. It is hard to describe in words an overall sound of this album as it has none, it feels a bit fragmented both in total and through several of the songs. It is music that clearly requires a certain type of listener and as a connoisseur of progressive rock, who better to review this album?
I think that this album shows brilliance… in two of the tracks. The single track The Malkin Jewel and the following Lapochka are great tracks with the former being very inspired by Pink Floyd I would assume and the latter being just a good song and the only coherent bit of music on the entire album. I think this album is just too fragmented, too much self fixated and too anal to be really interesting. And the fact that the playing time is well past the hour hardly qualifies as a positive, it is too much and sometimes it is so boring that you imagine yourself falling out of a plane without a parachute or something else more exciting than those parts. Thing is though that there are flashes of brilliance all throughout the album which sort of gives the same disappointing feel as having seen a JJ Abrams film, there is great tension and suspense being built up but when everything is to be completed (in the last act of the films, and the final adjustments on the album) it fails completely in something that is as spectacular as it is pointless and poor. So instead of a leaving it with a sensation of satisfaction and feeling challenged you leave with shrug.
In the end I think that this is a decent album, it has some flashes of greatness but the overall feeling is one of slight disappointment as you cannot help up thinking that it could have been so much better. The band are just too full of themselves to really manage to make a great album, I think you have to respect the skill involved and the innovative ideas behind this album but innovative ideas and challenging song structures alone never make a great album. I think that they should have stood back, looked at what they had done and realised that with a bit less delusions of grandeur Nocturniquet would have been so much better.
HHHHHHH