Band:
Jessica Åhman : Vocals
David Lidell : Guitar
André Berntsson : Guitar
Andreas Tiberto : Keyboard
Alexander Bringsoniou : Bass, Chapman Stick
Sven Funseth: Drums
Discography:
Black Morning Sun (2011)
Guests:
Info
Released 1/12-2011
Reviewed 10/12-2011
Links:
akribi.org
sofiatalvik.com
myspace
makaki
Musically I would say that on all accounts this is the metal version that is the most similar to the original versions, not only is it female fronted but the songs are not destroyed by boring metal riffs, the original melodies are very recognisable all the way through which is a difference from the earlier metalised versions which was mainly over riffed which made them quite different from the original songs. Sure they have added some distorted electric guitars and there are some riffs added as well but in most respect Akribi’s versions feels quite a lot like metal versions of Sofia Talvik’s originals. Sure they have some own touches as well, like some strange growly vocals in the first song and some soloing and sounds that we haven’t heard in the songs Sofia performed on her version of E, these are quite small however so they not that easily audible at casual listening. Akribi’s E is half a minute longer than Sofia’s at sixteen and a half minute playing time. The songs are of course four like all earlier versions and like the original E.
I would say good about this EP and the best one by the metal bands which may be because it is the only one that isn’t ruining the songs by making them decent heavy metal songs at best or making them poor heavy metal songs at worst. Akribi seems to honour the original melodies and metalise them in a very good way, quite a melodic brand of heavy metal which it usually tends to be when they have a female singer. The second song In the Garden is better than the song by Sofia I think, the first on 7 Miles Wide is much worse and the ending track being the best on the EP is not better than the original song by Sofia but still a very good song.
One problem for this band at this EP I would say is the female singer, she does alright but she is not particularly good to be fair and that is a slight letdown for this EP but not a big one. The strange growls in the first track is another thing that isn’t particularly good, in fact it is completely unmotivated and bad, but other than that there is nothing to complain about with this EP, it is well made, it has a good sound and the original feel of the songs is kept making this EP a great metal version of Sofia’s pop songs.
I think that in the end the L.O.V.E kicks the shit out of the H.A.T.E but the last letter is quite even and hat the quality been similar in the earlier metal versions it would have been another matter. Akribi does without a doubt the best part of the H.A.T.E and with that they also end that project in a very good way and also makes the overall feel of that part of the project a decent one. And with this EP the project is finalised and I would say that it ends in a great way and it has been an interesting project to follow, one thing to think of for next time would be to have better bands doing the metal versions because I think at least one of them really were sub-par and the three first parts were much more similar than Sofia’s were which is strange because they were made by three bands and not one artist. Anyway, hats off for Akribi, a great finish to this project, well done.
HHHHHHH
Previous reviews:
Sofia Talvik - E - Part Four of L.O.V.E
Hate Squad - Katharsis
Yes - In the Present - Life from Lyon
Previous articles:
Mystic Prophecy
Coronatus
Majesty